Concurring
Agreeing with the outcome of a court decision but for different or additional reasons than those stated in the majority opinion.
Concurring refers to agreeing with the outcome of a court decision but for different or additional reasons than the majority opinion gives. A concurring judge votes with the majority, so the result is the same. A dissenting judge, by contrast, disagrees with the outcome itself and would have decided the case the other way.
In contracts, concurring is not a drafting term. Businesses meet it when a contract dispute reaches an appeals court, where a concurring opinion may signal how judges could rule on a similar clause in future, even though it does not bind later courts.
What does “Concurring” mean?
A concurring opinion is written by a judge who agrees with the result reached by the majority but disagrees with the reasoning, or who wishes to add additional reasoning. The concurring judge votes the same way as the majority but explains their vote differently.
Concurring opinions are not binding precedent - only the majority opinion creates binding law. However, when no majority agrees on a single rationale, the concurring opinion that represents the narrowest common ground may be treated as the controlling authority under the Marks doctrine.
For businesses involved in litigation, concurring opinions matter because they signal where the law may be heading. A concurrence that garners support from multiple justices can foreshadow a future majority shift, affecting how counsel advises on litigation risk.
In practice, many teams rely on a contract expiry tracking system to stay on top of dates and obligations tied to clauses like this.
Key Elements
Agreement on Result, Not Reasoning
The concurring judge reaches the same outcome as the majority (affirm, reverse, remand) but follows a different legal path to get there.Non-Binding Persuasive Authority
A concurrence has no binding effect on lower courts. It may be cited as persuasive authority but cannot be relied on as controlling precedent.Marks Doctrine
When a court issues a plurality decision with no single majority rationale, the Marks doctrine treats the concurring opinion that commands a majority for the narrowest grounds as the controlling holding.Signal of Legal Evolution
Concurrences often telegraph where the law is heading. Attorneys and businesses monitor concurring opinions in key cases to anticipate future legal changes affecting their contracts and operations.Real-World Example
The Supreme Court rules 5-4 that an arbitration clause in a consumer contract is enforceable. Three justices join the majority opinion. Two justices concur, agreeing the clause is enforceable but on narrower grounds that would not apply to employment contracts.
If your business uses the same clause in employment agreements, the concurrence is the critical opinion to analyze. Even though it is not binding, it signals that five justices would limit the ruling's scope in employment contexts - putting your employment arbitration clause at future risk.
This is why many businesses adopt automated deadline tracking to ensure no critical dates are missed before they pass.
Sample Clause Language
N/A - Concurring is a judicial concept, not a contract clauseWatch Out For
Mistaking a concurrence for controlling law
Citing a concurring opinion as binding precedent is a legal error. Only majority holdings bind lower courts. Always confirm whether the opinion you are relying on commanded a majority.Plurality decisions
When a court splits so that no single rationale gets a majority, you may have multiple concurrences and no clear majority opinion. These "plurality decisions" create significant legal uncertainty.Don't let concurring deadlines catch you off guard
Key dates tied to concurring - renewal windows, expiry cutoffs, notice periods - can easily slip through the cracks when tracked manually. Missing them triggers automatic extensions, penalties, or lost rights. ExpiryEdge tracks every critical deadline and sends automated reminders before they're due - so nothing slips.
Instead of relying on spreadsheets or manual follow-ups, a centralized renewal reminder system ensures every deadline is visible, tracked, and actioned automatically.
How to Use This in Your Favor
Brief counsel on key concurrences before signing high-stakes contracts
When a contract clause's enforceability depends on recent case law, ask counsel to review not just the majority but also concurrences - they often signal how courts will rule in the next case.Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
No. Only the majority opinion creates binding precedent. A concurrence is persuasive authority at best and is often used to argue for evolving legal standards.
A concurring judge agrees with the outcome but differs on reasoning. A dissenting judge disagrees with both the outcome and the reasoning and would have ruled differently.
Concurring in the judgment means a judge agrees with the final result but does not join the majority's reasoning. This differs from a regular concurrence, where the judge joins the majority opinion and writes separately to add points. The distinction matters when counting how many judges actually support a given legal rule.
Yes, in some cases. When no single rationale gets majority support, courts may treat the narrowest opinion supporting the result, sometimes a concurrence, as controlling. In federal courts this is known as the Marks rule, after a US Supreme Court decision. Applying it is often contested, and courts disagree about which opinion is narrowest.
