Arbitrator
A neutral third party selected by the parties to hear their dispute and issue a binding decision in arbitration.
Arbitrator refers to a neutral private decision maker who hears a dispute and issues a binding award, chosen by the parties or appointed under rules they agreed. Many are retired judges or lawyers. Their power comes only from the parties' contract. So an arbitrator can decide just the issues the parties sent to arbitration.
In a business contract, the arbitration clause says how many arbitrators there will be and how they're chosen. It may set required skills, such as experience in construction disputes. It may also set a deadline, like 30 days after a demand.
What does “Arbitrator” mean?
An arbitrator is a neutral third party chosen to resolve a dispute through arbitration. The arbitrator hears evidence, applies the law, and issues a binding decision (award). The arbitrator acts as both judge and jury.
Unlike a judge, an arbitrator has only the power that the parties give them in the arbitration clause. Arbitrators are typically retired judges, practicing attorneys, or experts in the subject matter (engineering, finance, etc.).
Arbitrators are supposed to be neutral and impartial. However, confidentiality in arbitration prevents public exposure of arbitrators who show bias or error.
In practice, many teams rely on a contract expiry tracking system to stay on top of dates and obligations tied to clauses like this.
Key Elements
Neutrality
An arbitrator must be neutral and impartial. Conflict of interest must be disclosed. An arbitrator with undisclosed conflicts can result in award being vacated.Expertise
Parties can require arbitrators to have specific expertise (engineer for construction disputes, accountant for business valuation). Expertise increases cost but can improve decision quality.Authority
An arbitrator's authority is limited to what the arbitration clause grants. If the clause limits the arbitrator's power, the arbitrator cannot exceed it.Compensation
Arbitrators are paid for their time, typically $5,000-$10,000+ per day depending on experience. Parties usually split arbitrator fees.Real-World Example
You have a dispute with a software vendor over whether the software meets specifications. You and the vendor select a retired software engineer as arbitrator through the AAA. The arbitrator tests the software, hears arguments, and issues a binding award.
The arbitrator's technical expertise helps evaluate the software's compliance. The arbitrator's award is binding - you cannot appeal it to a court just because you disagree.
This is why many businesses adopt automated deadline tracking to ensure no critical dates are missed before they pass.
Sample Clause Language
Arbitrator Selection ClauseWatch Out For
Conflict of interest
Before an arbitrator is appointed, investigate potential conflicts (prior representation, financial interests, professional relationships). An award from a biased arbitrator can be vacated.Lack of appeal rights
An arbitrator's mistakes in applying law or interpreting facts are not appealable. Arbitrators have broad discretion, and awards are nearly final.Arbitrator replacement
If the arbitrator becomes unavailable or unsuitable, replacement procedures vary. Make sure the arbitration clause addresses arbitrator vacancies.Limited reasoning
Arbitrators often issue awards with minimal reasoning. You may not understand why the arbitrator ruled against you, making appeal challenges difficult.Don't let arbitrator deadlines catch you off guard
Key dates tied to arbitrator - renewal windows, expiry cutoffs, notice periods - can easily slip through the cracks when tracked manually. Missing them triggers automatic extensions, penalties, or lost rights. ExpiryEdge tracks every critical deadline and sends automated reminders before they're due - so nothing slips.
Instead of relying on spreadsheets or manual follow-ups, a centralized renewal reminder system ensures every deadline is visible, tracked, and actioned automatically.
How to Use This in Your Favor
Select arbitrators with care
If you can choose the arbitrator, select one with relevant expertise and a reputation for fairness. Poor arbitrator selection can result in a bad award.Conduct background checks
Before an arbitrator is appointed, research their background, prior awards, and reputation. Arbitration organizations maintain arbitrator databases.Require detailed reasoning
In your arbitration agreement, require the arbitrator to provide written reasons for the award. This helps with any potential challenge and clarifies the arbitrator's thinking.Set fee allocation
Specify upfront how arbitrator fees are paid: equally split, loser pays, or proportionally based on claims? This affects the cost of arbitration.Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
Usually yes. The arbitration clause typically specifies the selection process. Some clauses allow parties to jointly select the arbitrator. Others use the arbitration organization's list, or allow each party to nominate one arbitrator, who then select a third.
Conflicts must be disclosed. If an arbitrator fails to disclose a conflict, the award may be vacated. Before appointing an arbitrator, always inquire about potential conflicts.
Yes, an arbitrator can be challenged for bias if there is evidence of prejudice or conflict. However, the standards are high. An arbitrator's unfavorable ruling alone does not show bias.
It depends on the clause. The rules it adopts usually set the method. Often the parties agree on one arbitrator, or each side picks one and those two choose a third. If the parties can't agree in time, bodies such as the American Arbitration Association will appoint one from their lists.
Usually the parties split the fees, often equally, unless the contract or the rules say otherwise. The arbitrator may shift costs in the final award if the contract allows. Consumer cases differ. There, and in employment cases, institutional rules often make the business pay most or all of the arbitrator's fees.
